Review of Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas

7896527Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas. ★★1/2

Throne of Glass is a YA fantasy that felt like a compilation of YA tropes I’m not fond of. The heroine, Celaena Sardothien, is the best assassin in the world at the age of eighteen. She’s spent the last year in a prison camp but is offered the chance at freedom if she wins a tournament to become the king’s new personal assassin. However, for something nominally the focus of the book, the tournament doesn’t receive a lot of page time.

Throne of Glass has a slow start. It takes until halfway through the book for the main plot to finally arrive. And the tournament? It’s often skipped over in a few sentences summaries, which more than anything else tells you just how exciting this plot line is.

Instead, a lot of time is spent on the love triangle and how commenting on how amazingly attractive the various characters are and how great Celaena looks in her various outfits. I hate love triangles, and I especially hate love triangles where the only basis for the relationship is how good looking the people are. Besides, it’s not like either of her love interests had an actual personality.

Celaena herself annoyed me, especially at first. She’s vain and frivolous, and it feels like most of her assassin’s skills are told rather than shown. She doesn’t act like someone who’s killed for a living, much less the most famous assassin. She doesn’t act like someone who’s just spent a year in the harsh conditions of a mining prison. What even is her motivation? She wants her freedom, but when it’s literally staring her in the face she doesn’t take it. Instead she for some bizarre reason stays around to participate in the tournament to become the personal killer of a man she hates! None of this makes any sense!

There was an undercurrent of girl hate and “not like other girls” with Celaena immediately hating on the female courtiers (who are obviously all vain, frivolous and gossipy… much like Celaena?), with the only named courtier being a classic mean girl character type. As a bonus, she hated Celaena because she wanted to marry one of Celaena’s love interests. I am so tired of these plot lines. However, this whole section of the novel was ultimately saved from being completely terrible by the inclusion of Celaena’s friendship with a foreign princess, Nehemia. While she could have used more characterization (this is true for every character in the book), she had one thing everyone else seemed to be lacking: motivation. It didn’t take much for Nehemia to become my favorite character.

I really love books with good world building. Unfortunately, Throne of Glass does not fit into this category. It’s basically a completely generic medieval Europe/fairy tale world type. To make things even better, Maas outright lifted holidays from our own culture. Case in point “Yulemas,” a winter holiday celebrating the birth of the Goddess’s first son where people give each other presents. More than anything else, that displays the amount of creativity and imagination which went into the world of Throne of Glass.

Basically, Throne of Glass is a YA trope extravaganza. If that sounds like your thing, you might find it has value for fluff reading. However, it’s not a book I would recommend.

Advertisements

4 Comments Add yours

  1. Dina says:

    Thank god I’m not the only one who doesn’t like Sarah J. Maas.
    I haven’t read this series but I tried A Court of Thorns and Roses and only liked it a tiny bit. I’ll probably never finish reading the second book because of the exact same things you describe. It’s all about how beautiful everyone is and what outfit they are wearing. There is no plot whatsoever and the love triangle is incredibly forced.
    I just thought that soooo many people love this author, I must be reading her wrong. But it’s nice not to be alone with an unpopular opinion. 🙂

    1. And you just killed any idea that I might ever try reading A Court of Thorns and Roses! This was one of those books that I just have no idea why it’s insanely popular.

  2. Well, I enjoyed this first book more than you, but this is another YA series that went downhill for me after the first book. Like, if you thought this one was trope-filled, you really don’t want to know what the latest book is like. I am really torn on whether or not I should read the final one when it comes out, maybe I’ll end up forcing myself to hate read it just to say I finished.

    1. According to the economics class I’m in, the time you’ve invested in the series is a sunk cost and should not be considered when you’re weighing the marginal befits and marginal costs of whether to read that last book. From the sounds of it, I’d say the costs of having to spend time on that last book makes it not worth it.

      Sorry, I’ve got an exam coming up and it may be warping my thought process.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s